- Hot Topic - http://sciblogs.co.nz/hot-topic -
Signing up to nonsense: denialists plot letter to UN secretary general
Posted By Gareth Renowden On November 29, 2012 @ 6:03 pm In Environment and Ecology | No Comments
People send me stuff. Imagine my surprise when this morning’s mail included the text of a round robin email from Tom Harris — the Canadian PR man who heads the Heartland-funded denialist lobby group the International Climate Science Coalition [full text here ]. It gives an interesting insight to how these groups work behind the scenes. Here’s Harris appealing for signatures to a letter to UN secretary general Ban Ki-Moon :
Time is short if we are to mount a significant counterpoint to the scientifically invalid assertions already being broadcast by the 1,500 journalists and 7,000 environmentalists attending the UN climate conference now underway in Qatar.
Please find below our “Open Letter to the Secretary-General of the United Nations” to which we are inviting your endorsement. We have 61 qualified endorsers as of 9 pm EST, about 19 hours after we started to ask people.
Because we have an agreement with a major media outlet to publish the open letter on Thursday, I will need to know of your support within the next day if possible, please.
The denialist spin machine in action. The usual suspects queuing to sign up to a letter that’s going to be published — where? My guess would be the Wall Street Journal. Even more interesting is the nonsense these luminaries are so keen to endorse…
It’s worth noting that Harris is not giving anyone the chance to change his proposed letter. The usual suspects are expected to sign up without quibbling about wording. And they’re signing up to a thoroughly modern catechism of climate crank disinformation. Here are the key claims in the letter:
UK Met Office data shows “there has been no statistically significant global warming for almost 16 years”.
Global warming that has not occurred cannot have caused the extreme weather of the past few years. Whether, when and how warming will resume is unknown. The science is unclear. Some scientists point out that near-term natural cooling, linked to variations in solar output, is also a distinct possibility.
“Some scientists”? I suspect only the signatories to Harris’s letter expect a “near-term natural cooling” caused by the sun1 .
The “even larger climate shocks” you have mentioned would be worse if the world cooled than if it warmed.
A remarkable (and unsupportable) assertion. I will allow that an ice age might be an inconvenience, but as our emissions have effectively postponed  the next one for the foreseeable future, that’s the least of our worries.
The incidence and severity of extreme weather has not increased. There is little evidence that dangerous weather-related events will occur more often in future.
The letter goes on to quote from last year’s IPCC special report on climate extremes  (SREX), but ignores the key findings of that report: that increased extremes of hot weather and rainfall are being recorded, and are “virtually certain” to continue as the climate warms.
We also ask that you acknowledge that policy actions by the UN, or by the signatory nations to the UNFCCC, that aim to reduce CO2 emissions are unlikely to exercise any significant influence on future climate.
Harris and his tame signatories can ask, but to expect the UN secretary general to reject the advice of his own organisation and the vast majority of the world’s climate scientists on the basis of an error-ridden screed put together as a stunt by PR flacks for fossil fuel interests is a bit of stretch, I’d have thought. Harris’s letter will be just as effective as all the other letters he’s sent to UN secretary generals at climate conferences , and that is not at all.
Article printed from Hot Topic: http://sciblogs.co.nz/hot-topic
URL to article: http://sciblogs.co.nz/hot-topic/2012/11/29/signing-up-to-nonsense-denialists-plot-letter-to-un-secretary-general/
URLs in this post:
 here: http://hot-topic.co.nz/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/HarrisLetter.pdf
 Ban Ki-Moon: http://www.un.org/sg/biography.shtml
 a beat-up published by the Daily Mail: http://www.skepticalscience.com/misleading-daily-mail-prebunked-nuccitelli-et-al-2012.html
 World Meteorological Organisation points out: http://www.wmo.int/pages/mediacentre/press_releases/pr_966_en.html
 1: http://hot-topic.co.nz/signing-up-to-nonsense-denialists-plot-letter-to-un-secretary-general/#footnote_0_12419
 postponed: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-16439807
 special report on climate extremes: http://hot-topic.co.nz/stormy-weather-were-making-it-worse-and-theres-more-on-the-way/
 all the other letters he’s sent to UN secretary generals at climate conferences: http://deepclimate.org/2012/03/08/tom-harris-heartland-and-the-2007-bali-open-letter-to-the-u-n/
Copyright © 2010 Hot Topic. All rights reserved.