New Zealand’s organ donor service doesn’t seem to like Israel’s priority system.
Increasing domestic donations is a special challenge in Israel, where religious factors have historically constrained the organ supply. Despite a 300-year-old rabbinical ruling that an autopsy—and by extension, any post-mortem surgery—can be performed to save a life, many observant Jews consider the body inviolate in death. Taboos against mutilation are less of an issue in other Western countries, where consent rates—the percentage of brain deaths that result in donation—frequently exceed 70 percent. For most of the 2000s, Israel’s hovered around 45 percent—among the lowest in the developed world.
Today, however, Israel’s consent rates have jumped, to 56 percent in 2013—still low, but a shift that demonstrates a real turnaround in public opinion surrounding organ donation. The change is largely due to the public debate surrounding brain death that followed the highly publicized decision by the family of the Israeli soccer star Avi Cohen to disregard his wishes to donate his organs after a 2010 motorcycle accident left him brain dead—and to Israel’s adoption of a unique allocation system for organs that rewards those willing to donate. At a time when waiting lists are growing everywhere, including in the United States, Israel’s success has implications for a global transplant landscape that is in dire need of innovation.
The priority law also encourages living donation by giving donors the security that they’d be at the front of the queue should their remaining kidney – or any other organ – go bung later on.
The whole article over at Tablet Mag is well worth reading if you’re interested in the Israeli system. It’s a bit more complicated than one-year changes.
I’m guessing that ODNZ is a bit tetchy because a binding organ donor registry is again in political play. I’m more ambivalent about how much good that could do – or at least on its own. Combined with stronger payment for living donors, defraying funeral costs for cadaveric donation, and a priority system like Israel’s, well it could be pretty effective.